TAG / DATE
Single Post
2010, Sep 16
Japan seen from abroad 2

Conscientious talking about Kawada Kikuchi’s “The Map.”

Here is something else that is striking about The Map. Can you name a German photographer who has dealt with the past in the way Japanese photographers have? Maybe I’m missing something, but while Germany’s non-photographic artists have dealt with the German past, its photographers, curiously enough, for the most part have avoided the subject. This is all the more striking since Germany as a whole has made tremendous efforts to deal with its past – unlike Japan, whose prime ministers until very recently regularly visited a shrine honouring war criminals, but refused to even apologize for the country’s action during World War II.

Gotta give credit where credit is due, this is a lucid paragraph, perhaps the only one Colberg has ever written.

The post also features the following stomach-churning passage: “…when pressed, I elaborated on why The Map truly is a stellar book. Just as before, I was surprised about the stuff I heard myself say, and pleasantly so, if I may add. Son of a gun, I thought, that’s actually kind of interesting.

Sigh. The most respected “online photo critic” (he still is, right? i’m not really that close to the ‘scene’) is a man who would happily find the words to praise the color and texture of his own vomit.

Tags (1)

Japan seen from abroad

hi bie. hope i haven’t opened too big of a can of worms here.

Colberg said “Germany as a whole has made tremendous efforts to deal with its past – unlike Japan.” the actions and words of politicians is one thing, but what effect does that have on the “average Japanese person”? i would say that they are less conscious of japan’s history in this respect than the “average German person.” <— gross generalization

maybe this is because this information has sometimes been removed from textbooks? <— sketchy wikipedia link

Colberg either doesn’t know or rate Michael Schmidt.

http://photo-muse.blogspot.com/2008/03/michael-schmidt.html

Posted by Anonymous Photographer / September 18, 2010 at 6:23 pm:

I have no idea what fuss you find in the post. It seems rather pedestrian to me, in the sense that you’ve made too much of a couple of paragraphs beyond their actual meaning!

Yes, Japanese are probably, generally speaking that is, less aware of their wrongdoings than are the Germans. It’s in their nature I think to sweep the ugly bits under the carpet.

But I think Japanese are just an insular people, thus making them ignorant overall Hec, I recently met a woman who didn’t know that Elton John was actually gay!

hi AP, i’m not sure what “fuss” i found in the post either, so i don’t really understand your comment.

-->