I met a friend yesterday in Yokohama, we talked and drank for a while. In the course of our conversation he said something like this: “I really like American photography, it feels so fresh. To me, things in Japan are stale, everyone is doing the same thing here.” I said “really? It seems to me like so many photographers in America, especially graduate students, have these really ponderous artist statements, which doesn’t interest me at all. I feel like Japanese photography is something new.”
And so on. Of course there’s something obvious here (we both know our own cultures pretty well, so we’re interested in something different) but it’s the first time I’ve heard someone here really say that they were bored with things. We went on to talk about the idea of being “famous” as a photographer: if Eggleston or Friedlander walk down the street, do amateur photographers recognize them? Moriyama and Araki would get recognized. Then the over-polite service of the chain restaurant we were at prompted us to talk about how in Japan, photography is a way for radical individual expression. Of course there are some photographers who take a restrictive approach to their work, but the big names here (Moriyama and Araki) take a very open approach to allowing photography into their lives.
This conversation made me think of things a little bit differently, like it’s just as helpful to introduce foreign artists here as it is to introduce Japanese artists abroad.
昨日は横浜で写真関係の友達と会った。彼と、アメリカと日本の違いについて話した。彼が「アメリカやヨーロッパの写真の方が日本より新鮮」と。僕はちょっとびっくりしました。なんか、なんで日本の写真は新鮮じゃない??「アメリカには、写真家、特に大学院生はよく重過ぎるアーティストステートメントを書く。それがも面白くない僕にとって日本の方が新鮮!」と。
今考えたら、それはもちろんですね!自分の国の文化はもよく見るから、ちょっと飽きる。これからは、日本の写真家を海外に紹介するだけじゃなくて、もちょっと海外のひとを日本に紹介するかな?と思った。その後は、「有名な写真家」のはなしだった。例えば、アメリカにはアマチュアーカメラマンは全くエッグルストンとかフリードランだーの顔わからない。日本にそのアマチュアーカメラマンは荒木や森山のかお分かるでしょう?
日本語はいつもすみません!このテキストは酷い、それはよくわかる。でも最近はまた漢字を勉強してるから、練習ためにちょっと使ってみたい。
forgive me for commenting so late, finally catching up with tons of blog posts.
anyhow, this posts is very interesting to me because it more or less sums up how i’ve been feeling about the states, photography, and the film industry.
it’s interesting how for some of us americans, we’re pretty bored of what we are seeing so we try to seek out the new in far off lands. but then i get here, and realize so many creative kids here feel exactly the same and are hoping to come to the US to experience what we have.
as for photography in the states, i’m way with you about the current state of US photographers. most art schools there are either too focused on the grand central “artistic statement” (where sometimes the execution itself is pretty darn uneventful). everything starts to look the same after awhile.
as for your comment on eggleston or friedlander getting recognition here, you can argue there are plenty of low-key artist’s artist who would never find much recognition in the US unless if was someone who greatly followed their work. in a way, asia almost has it worst the way pop culture permeates into the everyday life of the average person.
anyhow. long comment. i hope i make it to japan sometime soon since i’m just a few hours away now. stuff like this is best discussed over whiskey.